Gloom & Doom


Yesterdays news that construction of new homes increased in October was good to see. It was great to see something positive written about our battered industry. Well don’t breakout the champaign bottles just yet.

When looking deeper into the information released yesterday, some troubling trends become apparent. The data shows that the gains were from multifamily residences. In this case primarily apartment buildings. New starts in apartments make sense when your consider how the housing boom of 2001 - 2005 depopulated apartments across the country. People moved from apartments into homes with the help of low interest easy credit. Now with foreclosure rates rising, credit tightening, and higher interest rates, fewer consumers qualify to buy a home. The multifamily residential industry is preparing to fill the void.

This uptick in multifamily building is masking further declines in single family starts. Some builders are moving from residential construction to commercial construction just to survive. “Builders continue to do what they absolutely have to do in this market downturn.” says Brian Catalde, president of the National Association of Home Builders in a article written on the NAHB titled INCREASE IN MULTIFAMILY CONSTRUCTION LIFTS TOTAL HOUSING STARTS IN OCTOBER Some economist are pointing to the drag on the overall economy that the housing sector is becoming. According to Brian Bethum and MSNBC we may be two quarters away from hitting the bottom of the downturn.

It is increasing clear. We can’t avoid the law of supply and demand. Until we reduce housing inventory, and increase the supply of qualified buyers, we are going to continue stumbling in a downward spiral.

The housing report for October was just released and the numbers are not good. Starts are up slightly, but permits still down. Single family housing numbers have dropped to levels not seen since 1991.

NAHB has released some information that is attempting to put a moderate to flat reporting on the market in their report of builder confidence.

Additional information will come out later today. Stop back for more details.

“La vie commence lautre cot du desespoir”
Life begins on the other side of despair.

- Jean-Paul Sartre

I’ve spent the last few weeks completely immersed in the gloom and doom of the new home and mortgage industries and it already feels like months. Journalists are starting to separate their thoughts into a few different groups.

  • It’s bad
  • It’s bad…but it’s gonna get worse
  • It’s bad…it’s getting worse…so who’s to blame?
  • Somebody has to pay for this

In general, there seems to be very little reporting of personal responsibility. No reporting of individuals finding unique ways to prosper in the face of adversity. No reporting of creative new products rushing to fill the vacuum of the disintegrating sub-prime market. You get the idea. But… Just because we have not seen it yet does not mean it is not out there.

In the coming weeks as we see more builders reporting losses, mortgage companies closing, more calls for government intervention, and yes the mandatory bunch of heads on a platter, I will be looking some nuggets of creativity to help fill the void. I don’t think I will find it coming from big monolithic companies, but rather small agile entreprenuers. Companies small and flexible enough to adjust quickly to the current upheaval in the market place.

In the meantime enjoy some of this weeks more memorable articles.

Area home-building slows to a crawl
By Gary T. Pakulski

Builders from the same local market are effected in different ways by the downturn

Hangover starts after real estate bender
By Leslie Earnest

Brad Cottrell was a paramedic when a friend introduced him to the high-rolling world of high-interest mortgage lending.

Borrowers are caught in backlash over loan defaults
By Emmet Pierce

Critics say the tough new underwriting standards that were imposed to prop up the sagging subprime mortgage market are harming some creditworthy borrowers by trapping them in high-cost loans.

Largest U.S. home builder’s earnings plunge 85%
by Inman News

D.R. Horton Inc., the largest U.S. home builder, today reported an 85 percent decline in quarterly earnings as market conditions continue to challenge the nation’s home builders.

U.S. home builders risk bankruptcy in 2008, experts say
By Steven Church - Bloomberg News

WASHINGTON: The collapse of the subprime mortgage market may push some big U.S. home builders toward Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection starting next year, according to bankruptcy advisers and lawyers who specialize in the real estate industry.

Builders Highlight Need for FHA Reform

The National Association of Home Builders (NAHB) today called on Congress to enact legislation that would reform and revitalize the Federal Housing Administration’s single-family mortgage insurance programs.


Builder profits, home sales in focus
Investors gear up for glut of quarterly reports and new, existing home sales

By John Spence, MarketWatch

BOSTON (MarketWatch) — Home-builder stocks could see plenty of action next week as investors prepare for a slew of quarterly financial releases as well as reports on March new and existing home sales.
The volatile sector has traded lower so far in 2006 as more evidence suggests the important spring sales season is off to a lackluster beginning. The subprime-mortgage debacle could postpone any potential rebound as lenders tighten their standards, and home builders are taking impairment charges now that land prices in many areas are falling back after the boom years.

I’d say it’s been my biggest problem all my life.. it’s money. It takes a lot of money to make these dreams come true.
- Walt Disney

It’s been another rough week for both the mortgage and new home industries. Builders are laying off staff, cutting subcontractors and reducing expenses in marketing and advertising. These reductions are just part of the story. The trickle down effect of the housing industry is being felt throughout the world economy. The United States housing industry has been a driving force in the global economy since early 2002. The recent meltdown of the sub-prime mortgage industry is causing the housing market to continue on its downward spiral and the signs keep pointing to the impact it will have on foreign investment markets.

It doesn’t look like its gonna get any better in the near future. So, What are we going to do? Survive is the obvious answer. We have to get smart. We need to look for ways to do more with less. Next week we’ll outline a few solutions that builders have come up with to better utilize their marketing dollars.

‘Bonnie and Clyde of mortgage fraud’ will call prison home

Matthew Bevan Cox — who, along with an accomplice was dubbed “The Bonnie and Clyde of mortgage fraud” — has pleaded guilty to mortgage fraud charges in three states.

No. 1 builder signals more housing blues
UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF AND NEWS SERVICES

DALLAS – The peak spring home-selling season is off to a slow start, builder D.R. Horton Inc. said yesterday, another sign that bad times in the housing market may last longer than expected.

Home prices set for first drop in 40 years
Chris Isidore, CNNMoney.com senior writer

NEW YORK (CNNMoney.com) — The National Association of Realtors said Wednesday it expects its measure of home prices to fall this year for the first time since the group began keeping track nearly 40 years ago.

Subprime `Debacle’ Will Delay U.S. Housing Recovery (Update5)
By Kathleen M. Howley and Sharon L. Crenson

April 11 (Bloomberg) — The subprime loan “debacle” will make it more difficult for borrowers to get mortgages and will cause U.S. home prices to fall this year for the first time on record, the National Association of Realtors said.

Median Home Price Projected to Drop
By ALAN ZIBEL and DAN CATERINICCHIA

Key Senate Democrats issued a report Wednesday detailing the housing market’s decline amid calls for federal aid to homeowners at risk of foreclosure.

“The good things take care of themselves. We want to find all the negatives.” - Wayne Huizenga, Blockbuster Video

We are introducing a new segment to the URBaCS blog called the Gloom & Doom: Week in Review. On Sunday evenings we will be posting our weekly findings relating to the mortgage and housing markets and will underscore important trends and challenges that these industries face. As time progresses we hope to offer some unique insights into ways builders are overcoming these challenging conditions.

Subscribe to this blog for weekly updates.